Power company says land lost for development could be made up by extending Pinecone Burke into Crown land

Larry Pynn, Vancouver Sun - Published: Friday, January 04, 2008

A private company is asking the Ministry of Environment to delete part of Pinecone Burke Provincial Park to allow a transmission line to connect with its proposed run-of-the-river power project in the upper Pitt River Valley.

Run of River Power Inc. says its subsidiary, Northwest Cascade Power Ltd., has submitted a park boundary adjustment proposal to allow for a 230-kilovolt transmission line measuring 4.6 km long by 30 metres wide through the 38,000-hectare wilderness park.

Run of River Power president Jako Krushnisky asserted in an interview Thursday that the project wont be feasible without going through the park, and believes the impact of the transmission line to be minimal -- a statement immediately refuted by conservation groups.

"This is in the best interests of developers, not the park," responded Gwen Barlee, policy director with the Western Canada Wilderness Committee. "The reason the transmission line is [proposed to be] going through the park is because its convenient for the developer and its cheap."

Krushnisky said the company has identified 473 hectares of Crown land suitable as grizzly bear and mountain goat habitat in the upper Pitt River that could be added to the park to make up for the transmission line.

The company says a total of 42 km of transmission line is needed to connect its proposed upper Pitt power project, currently under environmental review, with BC Hydros Cheekye substation near Squamish.

The Liberal government approved the Provincial Park Boundary Adjustment Policy, Process and Guidelines in July 2004, which allowed for amendments "on a case-by-case basis where there are compelling provincial economic, environmental and societal benefits that exceed preserving the integrity of the existing park boundary and values."

If the Pinecone Burke proposal is allowed, it would represent two firsts under the 2004 policy: the first transmission line okayed in a park in B.C. and the first park allowance for industry in the Lower Mainland. Earlier this year, B.C. allowed the deletion of 478 hectares for pipeline expansion through Mount Robson provincial park.

"What does this signal for the integrity of our park system for the future?" Barlee said. "It doesnt look very good. This is a government that has turned its back on provincial parks."

The B.C. government also passed Bill 30 in 2006, making it impossible for local governments to block run-of-the-river power projects, but that hasnt stopped them from taking a position.

Coquitlam council has voiced "strong opposition" to the power proposal, Maple Ridge has "serious reservations," and Pitt Meadowss support is "subject to the mitigation of any negative environmental impacts."

The BC Parks website describes the Pinecone Burke as a "wilderness area protecting old-growth forests, numerous alpine lakes, rugged terrain, and remnant icefields."

Among the long list of conservationists lined up against the project is Order of Canada recipient Mark Angelo, rivers chair of the Outdoor Recreation Council of B.C. and head of BCITs fish and wildlife He said he is "very much concerned" about the project, given the great ecological values of the upper Pitt, an area "that deserves to be protected in its natural state."

The companys project would divert waters from eight streams -- Bucklin, Steve, Pinecone, Homer, Boise, Shale, Corbold, and East Corbold -- in the remote upper Pitt River Valley north of Pitt Meadows. "One of the reasons Im involved in this business is because I am concerned about the environment," Krushnisky said. "I am a green guy."

Dan Gerak, owner of Pitt River Lodge fly-fishing resort, is adamantly opposed to the project.

"So, really what they are proposing is to ruin our parks so that they can save money. Why are we even creating these parks when years down the road industry can apply to change the boundaries and land can be removed?"

Environment Minister Barry Penner is on holidays and unavailable to comment.

Dolly Varden, bull trout, cutthroat trout, rainbow trout, steelhead, and five species of salmon live in the upper Pitt River, along with species at risk such as marble murrelet, peregrine falcon, and northern spotted owl.